My first meeting was with the health and human services worker. She is no-nonsense, the way that they all seem to be after a while. I guess it comes with the job. You just can't hear all the terrible stories and witness all the terrible events and not have to find a coping mechanism in order to continue to do your job. She sits across from me and opens her notebook. Her voice is monotone.
Victim is a 4 years and 1 month old Caucasian male. This worker went to the home to make an unscheduled visit at 8:45 p.m. Door was ajar, so worker walked in, calling for residents. They were sitting and watching the television. They were unprepared for a visit. House was not clean, evidence of drug paraphernalia in ashtrays, ie a roach clip and a small baggie of what looked to be marijuana. Rolling papers. Residents jumped up and Mary Smith, the victim's mother walked quickly to the kitchen. This worker followed her and was witness to her opening a small cupboard door under the sink. The victim crawled out, wearing only underpants and squinting against the kitchen lights. Mary Smith reported that the child was being punished for an infraction. Worker knelt down to talk to victim, but he was unresponsive, looking at the floor at all times. When worker asked Mary Smith what the infraction was, she stated that the child had "peed his pants." The kitchen was in bad squalor, worker witnessed a large rat behind a garbage can. Worker made the decision to remove the child from the premises and to call police to report drug paraphernalia, although all evidence of drugs had been removed when she returned to the living room. Worker informed the residents that the victim would be removed at this time. They did not comment. Worker requested that the victim be dressed and went with Mary Smith to observe dressing of victim. Mary Smith picked up dirty clothes laying on a bedroom floor and dressed the victim. No words were exchanged between Mary Smith and the victim. Worker noted that at previous visit a bed had been in the room but now there was no trace of it. Worker remitted child to her car where they waited for police to arrive. When police arrived to search house, worker and victim waited in police car for a report to be made. No drugs or drug paraphernalia were found at consequent search. Victim was taken to temporary foster care with Ann Jones of 111 Walnut St. The following Monday, worker visited the foster care placement home and was able to speak to Ann Jones who seemed to have established a workable rapport with victim. Ann Jones reported that victim had stated to her that he slept in the small kitchen cupboard at night "as soon as the blinds were shut." Ann Jones reported that on the first night of victim's stay, she had bathed him and put him in a bed but the child was trembling, so she moved him to the sofa where he fell asleep next to her and she remained with him for the rest of the night. The next day was quiet. Victim ate what he was served and sat quietly; did not talk or play with proffered toys. In the evening when Ann Jones went to shut the blinds at her home, the victim began shivering and crying but still would not speak. After several attempts to comfort victim, he finally was able to tell her that "as soon as the blinds shut, it was go in the cupboard time." Victim also reported that when he struggled or refused to cooperate that he was tied to a wooden hanger and hung upside down in a closet until he promised to be quiet and obey. This worker believes that this child may be in need of psychological assistance at this time and requests an initial meeting with foster parent, who has more to report and then a meeting with victim as soon as possible. Foster parent will accompany victim to medical facility for an overall physical evaluation. Possible speech delays as well.
The next meeting was with Ann Jones, the foster parent. I have learned a great deal regarding the foster care system in the course of my employment at my current job. In my opinion, they come in 4 categories:
1) Foster parent is not doing this for payment. This is a person who truly wishes to help children.
2) Foster parent is doing this for payment, but they are kind and loving to the child.
3) Foster parent is doing this for payment. They are not abusive to child, but there is no real bonding. Foster parent attends to the child's physical needs but no emotional connection is there.
4) Foster parent is doing this for payment. They care only about the money and have no concerns whatsoever for the child. This is the foster parent who will swear up and down that the child in their care is showing symptoms of autism. They will have boned up on the symptoms and sometimes out and out lie about how the child tends to avoid eye contact, wave hands uncontrollably, engages in repetitive behavior and does not seem to understand social behavior. They are savvy in knowing that if the child is diagnosed with autism or any other behaviors in the spectrum, that they will receive more money.
Unfortunately, most foster parents that I have seen fall into either category 3 or 4. There are some exceptions. Ann Jones is one of them. She and her husband have been foster parents for years and have adopted three of the children who came to live with them as foster children. She is quiet voiced, honest and every child who comes into her care is very, very lucky. She is warm and loving, kind and generous spirited.
When I met with Ann to discuss "the victim" (and this is just jargon, all health and human service reports refer to the children as victims), I found that she had excellent insight into the child. Let's call him John Doe. She had done something extraordinary: she had gained his trust. He physically brightened at the mere sight of her and when she pulled him into her lap, he didn't flinch, but leaned into her gratefully. I knew that John would thrive under her care. And it made me happy. As always, I hoped that the parents would not regain custody but honestly? Most do. But, for now...he was safe.
Ann told me how John was still not sleeping well at night, tended to tremble violently at dusk each day as if expecting to be put back into the cupboard. This is not something that he will be able to shrug off easily. His fear will manifest itself over and over in his lifetime until he finds a way to overcome this difficult part of his life. IF he can. She said that he was taking small steps towards getting to know her children and his foster father but that he was still very clingy with her, still had fear that she would leave compounded with naughty behavior, seeming to almost push her away when all he sought was to be with her, feel protected.
Sometimes we, as humans, do this. We are so afraid of losing another that we guard against any bonding. It is easier. Safer not to expect much. John has had to learn this lesson at any incredibly young age.
Now, my job begins. His first session with me begins with me telling him my name and asking for his. He doesn't answer, just looks at the floor. I look at his dark brown hair and round blue eyes and privately wonder about the sort of person who could put a child in a dark cupboard swimming with vermin. Who could hang them in a closet like a skirt on a hanger.
I am very, very angry at those who have hurt this child. But, this is not the time nor the place, so I just sit with John and he and I play with the plastic farm set. I put a cow in the barn and ponder out loud what other animals should live in there with the cow. I pick up a chicken. Slowly, John begins to hand me animals. A horse. A goat. A pig. They all go in the barn. Next I pick up the boy figurine. Hmmm, I say out loud, where should he go? The barn or the house? Maybe he would like to sit up in the apple tree? It is quiet there. Safe. John puts him in the tree. I don't touch the mother or the father figures and he doesn't either. But, I hold up the cat and ask barn or house? John says house. The dog goes in the house too. I find another boy figurine and put him the tree with the first boy. John takes him out. Frowns. He says his first real sentence to me.
"The boy in the tree wants to be by hisself," he says.
Word.
I nod and soon we stop for the day. John looks around anxiously for Ann and there she is in the waiting room, smiling at him as she puts away her knitting.
They leave after we set up another appointment.
John is one of the luckier children. Not all these stories end with a loving caregiver.
On the way home, I stop to pick up milk and think about Liv, how nice it will be to hug her, to hold her. To know that she is safe.
I think back to my brooding over the last two days and I roll my eyes, disgusted with myself.
Get over yourself I think to myself.
Just get over yourself. You are so, so lucky.
And I am. No more complaining.
There are so many lost children out there. And so many will never be reached. But, we do what we can. We do what we can. And it has to be enough for now.
I turn on some Lady Gaga and listen to her all the way home...the volume up so loud that it causes a pulse in my temple. It feels good. Like being washed hard clean.
Goodnight to all the children of the world. Sleep tight. Sleep safe. And may someone show you a kindness today.
24 comments:
What a sad story and even sadder to realize that there are hundreds more like your John Doe that aren't being saved... Even sadder that this problem is regardless of boundaries. We tend to hear some stories like that here in Japan too...
Fuck
Just ... Fuck
God this just kills me and I know it happens a lot. I talked to a lady the other day and she had to put her (special needs but of legal age) son on the phone so I could add her to his account. He answered me and she was surprised because she said he is very shy. I told her, "I have a son with autism so I understand." She thanked me profusely, I told her that our kids are a blessing. Unfortunately some people are allowed to abuse the innocent but I do feel that some day they will reap what they sow.
Such a sad story. It must be so difficult to hear stories like that as part of your job. He's only one in so many. It's so sad to think there are more children like him.
How can people do this? Except I know the answer already, people so broken by their own upbringing and pain that they pass it on to their own children. The sins of the fathers indeed.
I am thankful that he has his foster mother in his life for now.
I have such a hard time with these stories... My mom's been a director of pre schools for over 30 years, and it's unfathomable the sheer disgusting shit she's seen done to children. The problem is also the state, who doesn't recognize a lot of what she's seen, only to find out later that, indeed, this kid's been abused or whatever. It's horrible. And she's also witness to many of the foster parents you are - it's just awful. Makes me want to kill people with my bare hands.
I have never wanteed children but there are so many times that I think "if I could get away with kidnapping that kid and taking them away from their awful parents, I would".
I understand that life is not fair, but it really is cruel sometimes in the fact that there are so many good people who ache to have a child and then there are horrible individuals who don't deserve to even own a pet yet they are graced with a child that they treat badly.
About five miles from where I live, in a trailer park just north of here, a little boy disappeared for years and hardly anyone noticed and the ones who did? Well, they did nothing. He had been kept in a dog crate by his parents. Tortured and then accidentally killed. Then they buried him and no one said a word. The parents had threatened the other children in the home into silence.
And you know as well as I do that there are far too many stories just like "John Doe" and Christian Choate.
Christian's life is what I fear for that little boy if he goes back to his birth parents. I hope he never has to live with them again.
You and I are a lot alike in the fact that we "get over ourselves" in very much the same way. I admire the work you do and I like you a heck of a lot, Maria.
Maria! You make me want to get my f-parent license back! OHH! It is really hard to imagine the way these "parents" think. I am so so grateful to have been blessed with my little D out of one of these situations. I hope this sweet child gets to stay with his new family and continues to heal from such a horrible start. The more I learn about how hard it is to deal with Reactive Attachment Disorder, the more stressful it seems to work with these suffering kids but they are so worth it!
good grief. yes. no more complaining from me either. i vacillate at times, now that our nest is emptier, about fostering. I know I couldn't, though I grateful for those who can. I could not bear to see a child given back to people so broken that they think nothing of breaking their own children. I kvetch about my job, but I will stop now and instead, put all those little John Does in my prayers.
Thank you for doing what you can.
C
Because of Jacks Downs Syndrome I read a lot on the internet about anything to do with DS, recently found so many blogs about Eastern European adoptions by American couples. Its so hard to comprehend that no one keeps their baby in these countries unless they are 'perfect', the orphanages struggle to look after these children but one they reach 5 they are transferred to adult insane asylums where they regularly die within 18 months. It sits heavy on my heart every day, I look at my beautiful baby, currently laying on his dads lap beside being tickled and cuddled while he happily babbles away, I wonder how anyone could walk away from a baby like him?
i have encountered many stories like this one, in my line of work. i walked in on a mom shaking her newborn baby to stop crying, had to take the baby and call social services/police/etc... at midnight one night. the baby began seizuring etc and had to be transferred to a NICU.. and i had to testify.
when i was a student nurse at childrens hospital, my first patient was a 4 month old chubby lil baby boy who reminded me of one of my own, who was in hospital due to his father's rage of him crying that he kicked him in the forehead with cowboy boots on, the baby was now blind, had the embedded boot print on his forehead (into the skull), and had bleeding on the brain.
all i did that whole shift was tend to him, i held him the whole time and kept wiping back my tears. it was aweful. i prayed for him and whispered loving things into his ear. i dont know what happened to him later. i had such a hard time leaving him there.
but i share your rage and pain in having to deal with stuff like this. you are a much stronger woman than i, maria, because i just couldnt handle it every day as part of my job. i would be the one who would want to take them all home with me.. as i'm sure you feel too, many times.
i hope all the people who hurt children and animals get their due in the end... the fucking bastards. if there is a hell, they all deserve to go there.
When I was a paralegal for attorneys who were appointed by the courts to be the legal representatives for children like "John Doe" I got to write up all the reports in just the way you did. I saw more of them than I ever wanted to see in my whole life and I live in a small town. I am not the least bit a "kid person". I could never be a foster parent. But dear GOD, I cannot understand how an adult human being could do those things to their own flesh and blood. All for a handful of white powder or a bag of leaves.
God bless Ann Jones. And you.
GG
Thank goodness for all the Ann Jones' of the world, and for counsellors like yourself and child care workers. My niece used to work for the Children's Aid and her job was the same as the lady you spoke of - i.e. apprehending children in need. She has since moved on to working with foster families. My former boss was a lawyer who used to do work for the Children's Aid Society. When I worked for him, his practice was limited to criminal law - mostly young offenders. I remember him telling me once that by the time the Children's Aid got involved with a child, it was usually too late. I sincerely hope that is not the case with this child and so many like him. The thought that there is even a remote possibility that he could be returned to his parents turns my stomach.
Such an incredibly sad story, and all too common. It reminded me of my work with battered women and children, which all these years later haunts me still. I join you in your hopes that little John's biological parents will not attempt to regain custody of him and that Ann, or someone like her, will be able to adopt him.
The second kindness needed themed post read today reinforces the thought, not enough people of kind enough but thankfully some truly are. We need every one we can get.
Stories like this definitely due put our problems into perspective. It is hard to comprehend this kind of abuse. I don't know how you deal with it on a daily basis without becoming bitter, but I do know that these children are blessed in that they are given the opportunity to work with you. We all know what a huge difference one tiny bit of compassion and caring can make. John is truly one of the rare lucky ones who has been given caring foster parents, I wish that was the norm instead of the exception. I wish our system could address the problem differently. I know too many children who come out of foster homes more screwed up than they went in. I wouldn't want the karma those foster parents carry.
What a sad story. I teach library skills in a public school and I know I've had kids with similar stories... so sad, so sad.
Ugh, i don't get it. how people can be so undeniably cruel to children. this makes me SO sad and angry!!!
I work in the "system" and it pains me to no end that abuse is more frequent, the lasting results are more severe, those who victimize are increasingly more sociopathic and my budget, available resources and the infrastructure are woefully inadequate to respond and assist.
One doesn't have to be a professional to see the sad state of so, so many children in our society. Just yesterday, I witnessed an obscenity-laced tirade directed at a child you looked to be less than two years old, whose mother wanted him to get in his carseat and buckle himself up. Though on occassion I have intervened when I witnessed such things happening it public, the frequency with it happens nowadays leaves me feeling like I am sticking my finger in a very small hole in a very large dam. Kids are arriving at elementary school age already so damaged, it is hard to imagine how or by whom or if the damage will be undone. And these children are the future of our country, our greatest natural resource.
clearly, we're all grateful you do the work you do... and ann, too...
we all send our love to john doe and all the john and jane does out there...
i've been thinking about his mom...
especially on father's day, maybe, i want to get the whole world to see the price patriarchy exacts on our planet... because i do believe there is a connection between patriarchy and abused kids...
our culture... much of our planet... is not set up to value nurturing... caretaking... patience... not really. it's not really what we value.
domination, success, bigness, physical strength, competetiveness... those are probably some of the values aliens would list as our values if there were to land here and write up a file on humanity like you haev to write up files on these kids.
it hurts everyone - men, women, kids... a lot.
it hurts our planet.
i know it might seem like a big leap to talk about the tragedy of this child's situation to a whole larger issue but i do think there is a connection.
i think about that mom. her life must be a nightmare of self-hatred, denial, and desperation.
i have a friend who works with those moms... she comes hoem exhausted frmo her job... from hearing their stories and the stories about their kids, many of whom are in the foster system.
sigh... okay... love to each of you... love to you... love to john...
love to what needs to grow inside the human heart to make such tragedies less and less likely.
zc
No words.
Just: thank you for the work you do, Maria.
Thanks for this harsh reminder, Maria. I will pray for children like this, and also stop complaining about stupid little things.
Holy shit, what have we come to as a species...
Post a Comment