Saturday, February 23, 2008

The truth hurts

Usually, I am sort of excited to write a new post. I have an idea and am running with it. This time, I feel a bit naked and scared.

Because if I am truthful, I won't look so good. But, I feel the need to tell the story and if I come across as I fear, well...okay. I yam what I yam and all that shit.

Bing was toodling around on the piano this morning and it was such a lovely little piece that I sat down next to her and asked her what it was. She told me it was an old song, and a very sappy song by a man named Joshua Kadison.

"Wanna hear the words?" she asked.

I said sure. So, she played the piece and sang the song and when it ended, I said, "I hope he got the girl and I hope she stayed put."

"Me too," she said and paused. And then she said, "Because I think of it as my Maria song."

I half laughed but to be honest, felt uncomfortable too. It hit close to home. I think I said something to the tune of I have never in my life asked you to live in a trailer by the sea or called you from Vegas at 5 a.m.

"You're missing the point," she said. And then she didn't say anything for a long time and kept playing softly.

I started to get up and she brought me back down with an arm. So, I sat and waited. Uncomfortably, I admit. I had a feeling that she needed to get this out.

She ended up talking for a long time, but basically what she said was this:

I have been in love with you since I was eighteen and your dorm partner. You never gave me a second thought for years. We are talking YEARS. I was always the friend who quizzed you, half carried you home from parties, listened while you went on and on about how you thought so and so was so hot. I was the sidekick. I was the one you never considered kissing, but I was always watching you. I always got the feeling that somewhere inside you knew that but wouldn't go near it.

She was right. I did know it. And no, I didn't go near it.

Then I went back to New Orleans to go to grad school and you went to Creighton and then you met Cory and well, I knew that was that. You both came and visited me, remember? You couldn't keep your hands off of each other. Late one night, you told me that you were crazy in love with her. You moved in together, bought a house together. And I am the one you called at 2 in the morning seven years later to say that you didn't love her anymore and you were afraid to leave her, that she had threatened to kill herself.

Another truth. Bing is the only one I felt I could talk to about that. I trusted her completely.

And then, yeah...she tried to off herself and I am the one who moved to Omaha because you sounded half dead on the phone and I was worried. I was the one who moved in and became your roommate. I am the one who heard you come home from work and then stumble around getting drunk for hours because no matter what I said, you thought it was all your fault. And I am the one who hung tough and stayed the sidekick, the best friend, when you went through women (and a few men, I might add)like water for years. I was always the one who went to the parties with you, went to the movies with you, went grocery shopping with you, but never went to bed with you.

Let me add here that Bing also dated many other women. But, I always knew that they were time killers. She never seemed too deeply in love with any of them. I don't know what I would have done if she had gotten really serious with someone. Would that have woken me up? I will never know.

You never seriously hooked up with anyone, always kept from anything too serious. You said it was because you were a pot who hated lids. I would sit there and smile and shake my head and agree that you were definitely not inclined to commit, but never once, not ever once did you consider giving me a try.

That isn't really true. I did consider it, but figured I would only end up fucking things up, so never acted on it.

So, then you decide that it is time to be a mother and I figured that was a good time for me to move back south, but I couldn't leave you. I would decide to go and then you and I would sit up all night talking and I knew I'd never be able to leave you. That I would just be your fucking Joan Cusack sidekick forever if that was what you needed. And then...Liv. I loved her from the second I saw her. I knew that I could parent this kid with you. I think you knew it too and you also knew that being a single mom was a helluva lot tougher than you thought it would be. So, you finally let me in. Remember that night you told me? It was like a business proposal. You were about that romantic. And I leaped at it like that crumb was a banquet.

She did. She and I were "together" for not quite a year when Liv was a baby. And then I realized that I just couldn't do it anymore. I hated being part of a couple. I could see Bing was ready to sign on for life and I just didn't deserve that sort of love, not when I couldn't love back yet. So, I broke it off. She went back to Louisiana for a couple of years. The whole break up was remarkably polite. Or so I thought.

You broke my heart. I went for over a year with my hand on the phone every single night, wanting to call you. But, I never did. And then you made the first move and called me. Remember that? You called me at 7 at night and we talked until 7 in the morning. You talked me into being friends. I can't believe I settled for that, but I did.

She did. And I called her because I missed her. So much. But, I wanted to be clear that this was not a get-back-together thing. That we could only be friends. She seemed open to it, almost eager for it. I honestly had no idea then that she harbored feelings for me. She said she was dating someone casually and I thought to myself that this was good, she had gone on.

And then, well..I ended up moving back, didn't I? I came for Christmas and didn't want to leave. I knew then that this was my life, good or bad. That I wanted you and Liv no matter what and however I could get you. We bought that house and I moved in with you. Didn't sleep with you, didn't get to touch you though. I watched you get interested in other women and yeah, it was hard, but in some odd way, I was happy for you. I had reached the point where I just needed to know that you and Liv were cared for and happy. And then, you know....that night on the balcony.

The kiss. Ventura Highway playing. Her arms going around me. And me thinking that if I was going to go in this direction again, I better THE HELL not hurt her again.

And then suddenly there we were at this crossroads. Do we stay or go? I was ready for both. I didn't trust you. But something was very different this time. You had changed so much in those years apart. This time, if it wasn't all romantic and hot and something out of a dream that I had stuck in my head for years, but never thought would really happen. You asked me if we could try again and I said yes.

You screamed YES.

So, now...here we are. The happy couple. Except every now and then I see you feeling your oats and not wanting the lid and I get scared. So, yeah...this is my Maria song.

I put my arms around her. Told her that I was set in cement in our relationship. That I would never leave again. Never fuck up that badly or hurt her like that again. She has me. My heart belongs wholly and forever to her.

She said she believed me and then laughed ruefully and said, "Well....kind of."

Then Liv came in and we went to visit a sick aunt and the moment passed.

But, I have been thinking and looking inward all day. Why am I with Bing? Is it for Liv? For me? For both of us? I DO sometimes chafe at the bit. I am not good at being in a relationship, really. I can be aloof and elusive and impossible to reach. I worry sometimes about Bing, feel badly that she is stuck on me and with me.

But, the truth is that I am finally where I fit. It just took me a long time to reach this place. And it pains me that I hurt her so badly in the process. I will never hurt her again. I will stay put. Weather the storms. Batten down the hatch.

The only gift I can give her now is that my heart is finally hers. Well, as much as I am able to give it to anyone. I am very lucky that she thinks it is enough.

Thank you darling Bing. I love you. I really do. I'm just...not good at this dance. But, for you I will waltz. I promise. Every day. Not going anywhere. I promise.

This is the song that Bing was playing on the piano this morning.

It doesn't make me look all that good. But, it is truthful. And real.

43 comments:

Earth Muffin said...

You come off as honest and human in this post and I think you are both very lucky to have each other.

moonrat said...

Oh, Maria. Thank you for writing this.

Trop said...

That's passion like I've never experienced, sad to say. I'm a lot like you Maria, I'm not especially good at the relationship thing. I'm aloof. Not sure why.

Heather said...

I got a big lump in my throat when I read this post, Maria.

I am so glad you and Bing have each other. It sounds to me like it was worth the wait.

DN said...

We live our lives, each pain making us who we are. The fires along the way either destroy us or make us stronger. The best we can hope for is we come out stronger in the end. Your post made me cry (again). As long as you both are honest it will work out. Have faith.

Gypsy said...

I understand exactly where you are coming from in this post Maria and you don't look bad at all. Would it have done Bing, or you for that matter, any good if you had gone to her before you were ready. It hurts when we can't love someone as much as they love us. We feel like we don't deserve them but no-one can help the way their heart feels.

It isn't anyone's fault and believe me I have been struggling with this very thing for at least a year.

You are a beautiful person Maria and you and Bing are lucky to have each other.

simonsays said...

In so many ways and on so many levels, you have written a post about me and my husband. Perhaps you don't want to know that I feel exactly the way you do, but I do. I am never ever capable of giving all of me to him, or anyone else again, but what he does have of me, he has forever. Thanks for this post Maria. And just so you know, I don't think Bing could do any better than you, you are the realest person I know. :)

MLC said...

Maria - I just posted a song for you and Bing on my blog.

When I read your lovely post, I thought of Cheryl Wheeler and a song of her's called "Almost".

It's a love song for grown ups and one I think that would touch you, and what you expressed here.

Peace-
MLC (a.k.a. Janet)

Hahn at Home said...

It makes you look human. And, Bing, well...it makes her quite a woman--and you too for loving each other.

Jeez, they should make a movie out of this story!

Tina-cious.com said...

First of all -- can I just say that I LOVE this song.

My wife's name is Jess (Jessie) -- and I always call her "Jessie-paintcha-pictures" :D

ok -- onto your post -- this was so beautifully written, first of all.

Second -- there's no telling how we travel the roads we do -- so many different things drive us -- block us -- but it's being happy when we reach our destination that matters.

I think you've found home. Your family sounds wonderful.

Close the lid.

CDJ said...

I don't think you come across bad here at all. I think you come across as someone who was scared to give herself fully to a person she deeply loved because she didn't think she was worthy or able.

I always said that I would never get married. "Forever is a really long time..." I watched almost every woman in my family go through a divorce, and lived through one as a child, and I didn't ever want to repeat those experiences. I also didn't have a lot of positive relationship role models, so I really didn't think I knew how to do it. How to be part of a couple. I'm too selfish, independent, crazy, closed-off. But then I met Hubbz and like you said, it was like we just fit together, and then I really wanted to marry him. I'm so glad that I did and that we have this wonderful family. But when it gets hard, I still sometimes find myself driving around running errands and wondering how far I could get if I just kept driving. I'll never do it, because of the boys, but the thought is there, in the back of my mind.

I guess what I'm trying to say is, you're not alone. And sometimes all the success and love we earn as adults can do nothing to erase all the f-ed up stuff that happened to us as kids... But that doesn't make us bad people or unworthy. Just maybe a little harder to love sometimes :-)

Angelissima said...

The meaning/message of love changes as we grow older. Ultimately, to be aligned with a person with whom you can trust, respect and see yourself grow old with overthrows the emotional roller coaster we were so accustomed to in our younger years.

You have security and solid bedrock with Bing.

I can totally relate to the "no lids" analogy. I get the "urge for going" (in more ways than one...)
too. Its in our nature.

The guilt must make you very uncomfortable sometimes.
Joni Mitchell Urge for Going

Lachlan said...

The honesty of this -both Bing's thoughts and your post- is refreshing, and so very human. And more common than I think any of us wants to believe.

Reality is a funny thing. I think people see it as black and white, as immutable. The sky is blue. The grass is green. People are always in love 100% and couples have the same level of commitment and expressions.

Hah. As if.

I am not as aloof as you, Maria- at least not in the same way. But EVERY time you write something in this vein, I am nodding my head thinking "I recognize that." I have been, and remain, there.

Why am I aloof/at times withdrawn? It comes down to two things: my parents and the first couple serious relationships I had. With my parents, it was a fairly non-affectionate home with a lot of criticism from my Dad. I am a sensitive person, so I withdrew a lot to protect myself.

With my relationships, in the first I fell 100000% in love and gave all of me, only to have my heart crushed into smithereens. In the second, it was role-reversal; she fell for me like that and I withheld because I was scared of getting hurt. And in the end, I did and I hurt her as you hurt Bing. The difference is we never recovered a friendship and I never was able to understand what I'd done till years later.

Now, with Bayou... we fit. We just get each other. And even when I have withdrawn, she knows that it's not a sign of potential break up or whatever... it's just me. It never last for long, and she lets me be. She knows my past and understands how I came to be this way. In return, I do my best to communicate and not stay too internal for too long.

It's not always easy. Sometimes she needs more than I can give. But it always works out in the end because I want to have that lid. And I want it to be her.

Don't be too hard on yourself. At least you know you, and Bing does too- that's precious.

Rebecca said...

Beautiful post - so honest.

dive said...

Dammit, Maria. You just made a 49 year old Englishman cry like a baby.

Gina said...

(my comment is very long winded and kind of trite so i won't feel bad if you were to delete or edit it out. :))

They say that in every relationship there is the lover and the beloved and that these roles can and ought to switch off from time to time, otherwise, eventually the lover feels...unloved.

I also heard that the things you do for the other person, does not made them love you more, but causes YOU to love them more.


Though your relationship with Bing seems free from abuse, your story reminds me of the way I have always felt towards Al, my ex. Since I was 16, AL has always been the one to say he loved me. Always there to make things fun and better and make me feel wanted in a certain way. He was always giving of his time, and everything. I appreciated him and loved him deeply as a friend which broke his heart. This sounds horrible but I just wasn't that into him and could not fake it. I tried seeing other people. He was just always there, always hurt. I left the state at 25 hoping that he would move on as well. After a broken marriage at 28, and feeling rejected, I moved back and 3 years later, we became 'just friends' again. We waited 7 years, until I became overwhelmed and sick of my single girl struggles. Like you, it was my idea to invite him back into my life. Couldn't get close with anyone else. He met my needs for security and accepted me as I was. It seemed inevitable that I would choose him. Of course he was thrilled about that. Everyone thought it was a 'fairytale' marriage. Al is a good man, Dependable. Loving. Faithful and true. If I wasn't already in love with him, maybe I would have fallen in that direction. In the end, the realiry was off by almost 180 degrees. I don't know if it was my distance that brought out his abusive side or his abuse that created the distance but I tested him and broke the man dowm!

We are much better friends today.
Maybe our our personalities find people who will love us as we can not love them back. I don't know. But if you can find out what Bing needs to feel loved ( time, gifts, affection, respect, communication ) and give those things to her your own feelings will grow. I personally have grown to appreciate friendship...sometimes it's hard to let anyone get too close.

Jade said...

I can relate to this post so well. I have a similar thing with my man. I know he feels things differently to me, but I also know I am a better person and a better mother because this relationship doesn't consume me like others have. I've realised, like you seem to have, that there are more important things than being wildly inlove all the time, more sustainable and healthy things.

Val said...

Maria, I second a few comments said before me.
This DOES so sound like a perfect 'chick flick' movie... and you really should close the lid, as you & Bing sound perfect for each other, in the sense that you both 'get' each other.
It's a fit, as you said. And really, that's really all that is important.
Your writing blows me away, as does your honesty.
And I love that song.

Gypsy said...

Hi Maria, Since you liked my statues so much I have included another one just for you because it reminded me of you and Liv. Hope you like it.

zirelda said...

Wow. That is really cool Maria. I'm going to think about this the next time I just want to ditch everything and run.

greymatters said...

I'm just plain speechless. And in awe, of both the story and your writing.

Old Crone said...

Maria,

Thank you so much for sharing this.

Kate said...

As a few other have said, I can relate to this post, because it reflects my relationship with Simon. He is more like you, and I am more like Bing, emotionally. I pursued him for years. He broke off or poured cold water on the relationship for years. Six years. Then, it altered somehow. We got married, and we've been doing well together for 16 years. BUT. I'm like Bing. I'm always aware that I was the one who loved more. Who got hurt, but kept coming back for more. All my life, I'll wonder if he...settled for me? If I finally just wore him down? All this time passes, and I'm still accutely aware that I'm married to a man who did not even tell me he loved me until our wedding night. Talk about a leap of faith. It still ranckles.

Fusion said...

This is a beautiful testament to love Maria.

Just because it takes time to get there doesn't mean the journey isn't worth it.

Bing sounds like a very special woman to me.

Excuse me now, I have to go get a tissue...

Melissaria said...

AS many oter people have said already, I shouldn't imagine that there will be too many people in long-term relationships that didn't read this thinking 'oh I so know where you are coming from...' Most of us have probably sat on the other side of the fence as well, I know I have...

I think we all sometimes need to readjust our lids a little, perhaps to let off a bit of steam, and keep things bubbling away nicely. It makes you sound, well - like other people, but perhaps more honest and self-aware!

Stacy said...

It just sounds honest and human to me, Maria. We all go through doubts about our relationships and some doubts are longer and run deeper than others. Doesn't mean we aren't in it for the long haul, though.

BBC said...

A lot of people don't like the truth.

Elle said...

I love the honesty here. I mean it shows your both in your most vulnerable states - and I think it's awesome that you two overcame a lot to be together.

suesun said...

You have managed to put into words what so many of us feel in our hearts. I am you, Maria, in my marriage. I admit to myself sometimes that I "settled", but it was for a good man who is a good father and good friend. I love him, but it's okay not to be crazy in love all the time. That would have killed me. I could never admit this to him, though I believe he knows it. The openness you have with Bing about this astounds me.

There comes a time in our life when we know what we need, and we seek it. For me, it was finally the realization that I deserved to be loved the way he loves me.

I indulge my need to wander by leaving town for a few days every few months. Our time apart is what always makes being together better. Not saying he doesn't "worry" about me when I'm gone, however....

I'm still crying......

Scout said...

Wow, Maria, just look at the comments you have received from this post. You have touched a nerve because you were willing to be open and honest and make yourself vulnerable in front of everyone. You really have that gift.

And I don't think you look bad--you look human, and you are a treat.

sari said...

Maria, you inspire me to not worry so much about what will happen or may happen, but to just be with it. I've been married almost ten years, but I think because there was so much divorce in my family I hold a bit of myself back and I don't want to do that anymore. I don't even think about it much but I'm conscious of it now. thanks.

the only daughter said...

What gm and many others have said. Wow.

Anonymous said...

Beautiful because it si honest. Honey, none of us look good when we write honestly about our relationships, they aren't all peaches and cream.
Thank you for sharing this.
~Diana @ Stuck in Elmo's World

Pendullum said...

What a truly moving lovestory...
And now I am off to listen to Bing's Maria song...
I hope I do not cry anymore than I am now...

Ingrid said...

What a beautiful, honest post, Maria. It doesn't make you look bad. And it rings very true. Thanks for sharing it with us.

heartinsanfrancisco said...

Such honesty is very beautiful, and rare.

I have been married three times and the present one is really good, but I, too, have commitment problems. I hope that my loyalty makes up for it, and the fact that I really love him.

I will never leave because I believe this is as good as it gets, for me, and because he needs me. He has early-onset Alzheimer's and there is no fairness in that, but at least he won't have to go through it alone.

Love is so very complicated, but it's the best thing we can give each other.

Fate's Granddaughter said...

Like so many of your posts, this really hit home. You are so brave for being able to be honest about the past, and for letting Bing say what you already knew.

Fate's Granddaughter said...

Like so many of your posts, this really hit home. You are so brave for being able to be honest about the past, and for letting Bing say what you already knew.

Rebecca said...

I think Bing and Brian would have ton to talk about. Thank GOD nearly half the nation separates them! That said, I don't think either of them would say any of these thing out loud. I've never known Brian to say a bad word... I am the one that chafes, that chomps at the bit and stomps her food. Emotionally I take flight in a hot second, leaving for days at a time, though my body is present. I sometimes write of (bitch about) abandonment, but have been guilty of it as well. I am not good at relationship dances, I occasionally succumb to silly infatuations, doing the what if thing...I do belong to Brian, and I won't leave. But every so often the urge to take flight is just this side of irresistable.

I am glad you found your home. And I am truly sorry Bing suffered. You don't look bad in my eyes for this, as to do so would be to equally condemn myself. You are human, with some big hurts that damage trust and makes one more prone to chafe. But honest enough to address it...THAT's big.

jlb said...

...there is something in the brutal honesty of speaking one's truth that has the power to touch others..you've done that...
thank-you.
j.

Snooker said...

Maria you write the truth so eloquently. I enjoy the way you write, and obviously I'm not alone.

But what strikes the chord for me, and I suspect for so many others is your honesty. Things most of us would hardly be able to admit to ourselves come out of your keyboard and reach out to touch us all.

Thank you for your openness and your willingness to share.

Gillette said...

What a beautiful post. I am here at Fusion's referral and so happy to have found you.

In the end, I have no idea what it means to have a soul mate. But I don't necessarily think it means that they are only the ones where things are all rosy and firewors fly. Sometimes those relationships are the hardest and most painful...because soul work sometimes is hard.

Then there is another kind of the soul mate who show us unconditional love. And the question is...how much undconditional love can you stand and feel OK with?

Perhaps we can't feel the same depth, but you obviously find love here...deep, long lasting safe harbor for yourself and your child. How/why can that be "wrong?" And it's not like you've lied to her. She gets the drill and simply asks to be allowed to love you. Wow... you are SO Blessed!

Personally, I stopped trusting that "falling" sort of love awhile back. For me, real love comes in little snatches, unbidden. Candles are just as pretty as fireworks, but last way longer.

Thanks, again, for this post! You are a gem.

eleKtrofly said...

so beautiful. so honest and intimate.

::a single tear:: there at the end.

(bless you)